Global Analysis from the European Perspective. Preparing for the world of tomorrow

Why the Italian government can’t resolve the problems of Mediterranean smuggling boats? Because it doesn’t want to

The rule of law is often invoked as a Western value that “populist” movements want to destroy, yet the establishment’s own governments have long suspended that very same rule of law when it comes to immigration. The most evident example of this is the immigration policy started by the Italian Letta government in 2013 and continued since then under the Renzi government.
In October 2013, the Letta government, facing waves of refugees escaping the chaos of Western backed-Arab Spring in Libya, which later transpired as nothing more than insurgencies of Islamic radical groups, launched the operation “Mare Nostrum” or “Our Sea”, which consisted in the use of the Italian navy near Libyan waters to rescue asylum seekers from the African coast.

As noble as its motivation may be, a side effect of the operation was to encourage even more people to undertake sea travel because now they are certain that the Italian navy will rescue them. The result was a 224% increase in the number of boats leaving Libya, which translates into an average of almost 10 million euro a month for the Italian government1)Immigrazione: il flop di Mare Nostrum, Il Sole 24 Ore.
In November 2014 Mare Nostrum was replaced with the EU-coordinated and funded Triton, covering a smaller part of the Mediterranean at the cost of 3 million euro a month. The official reason for the Triton operation is to control borders, however once we look at facts the goal of the operation is simply to bring in as many people as possible, regardless of whether they are refugees, economic migrants, legals or illegals. Since then, smuggling channels instead of being stopped have multiplied.

An established practice since the “Mare Nostrum” operation, continued under Triton, was for smugglers to launch a rescue signal to the patrolling navy and request assistance. In the meanwhile, NGOs pursuing the “open borders” have joined forces with them, assisting anyone, legal, illegal, refugee, who wants to reach Europe2)Caught in the act: NGOs deal in migrant smuggling, Gefira3)NGOs Armada operating off the coast of Libya, Gefira4)The Americans from MOAS ferry migrants to Europe, Gefira.


The European Commission that is responsible for Frontex, and what follows border controls, has a clear opinion on the matter. Commissioner for Home Affairs, Migration and Citizenship Dimitris Avramopoulos said: Another important element that emerged strongly from the discussions on countering smuggling is that NGOs – and local and regional authorities – which provide assistance to smuggled migrants shall not be criminalised. I fully agree with this, of course, as I also agree on the need to protect the fundamental rights of those who are being smuggled. Those who we need to punish are the smugglers!”5)How can EU action against migrant smuggling be more effective? European Commission

Punishing the smugglers, unless they are part of NGOs, means the problem can’t and won’t be solved, because NGOs will always be free to smuggle migrants. This continues a well-established tradition; during the Monti government in 2011-12 a Ministry for Integration was created and given to Andrea Riccardi of the “Comunità of Sant’Egidio”, the prominent Italian open borders NGO. “Comunità of Sant’Egidio” runs projects such as “Humanitarian corridors”. The project funds an alternative route to bring people into Italy. Andrea Riccardi told the French media that he is convinced that Europe must open its borders.6)Andrea Riccardi, a soul for Europe, LavieThe Ministry  was then given to Cecile Kyenge, a black woman born in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, who set herself a task of drastically reducing the requirements for acquiring Italian citizenship. She proposes a law that would give citizenship to the children of immigrants if they are born on Italian soil. Under Renzi, the ministry was reduced to a department within the ministry for Home Affairs, and handed to Mario Morcone, again affiliated with the “Comunità di Sant’Egidio”.

What happens once migrants of all kinds reach Italian soil? They are sent to refugee centers, where they can apply for the status of refugees. It should be noted that Italy has long run out of places for asylum seekers, and so the government is paying hotels, hostels or citizens in general to take in people.

Here a common practice for those who know that their application will be rejected is to destroy their documents beforehand7)Establishing Identity for International Protection, European Migration Networkso that the time to identify them increases exponentially. Experience has shown that centers eventually become overcrowded, which turns out to be an occasion for migrants to riot, destroy properties and finally escape and become illegals.8)Migrants, 40 fleeing hotel in Sulcis bloc and the anus State, Corriere9)Cie revolt in Milan: flee three irregular, gd-notizie10)Directed to the Cie, agents arrests 10, Migranti Torino11)Lampedusa, via transfers. flight of immigrants from the cie in Turin, RAI 12)The illegal immigrants are in Italy after being expelled, Il GiornaleIf they do not escape and their application is rejected, they are expelled. Expulsion however is voluntary and data shows that approximately only 50% of expelled migrants actually leave, probably to another EU-Schengen country, with the rest becoming illegals.

As the “Mafia Capitale”13)Mafia capital, Buzzi: “With immigrants will make a lot more money than with drugs”, Il Fatto Quotidianoscandal has shown, a collusion between members of the ruling Democratic Party controlling immigration-related institutions within the Italian state, including refugee centres, NGOs and the organized crime ensures that migrants are employed at the expense of Italian taxpayers and for insignificant hourly rates, providing massive illegal profits for the racketeers. An infamous quote of a member of organized crime reveals how immigration is now a more profitable business than drug trafficking.

“Do you have any idea how much I make on these immigrants?” Salvatore Buzzi, a mafia affiliate says in a 1,200-page wiretap from early 2013. “Drug trafficking is not as profitable”. “We closed this year with a turnover of 40 million but… our profits all came from the gypsies (Roma people),on the housing emergency and on the immigrants,” Buzzi said. That was in 2013, when 20.000 immigrants arrived in Italy. In 2016, 180.000 immigrants arrived in Italy.

Corrupt politicians like Giuseppe Castiglione (NCD, partner of the ruling Democratic party), working for the Home Office, with the official mission of ”favouring the integration of those in need of international protection” in reality work to ensure profiteering from the crisis. Illegal activities range from the assigning refugee centers construction to Democrat-related cooperatives in exchange for bribes to transferring asylum seekers and illegals to the Italian countryside and having them employed in the agricultural sector for an hourly rate between 1 and 3 euro. When it comes to women, immigrants themselves organize prostitution rings within the refugee centers or sell them to work in the Italian streets.14)Sicilian Mafia Cashes In On Desperate Immigrants, La Stampa

Immigration, a tale of willingly lax enforcement of the rule of law, smuggling, dishonesty, slavery and, ultimately, destroying Europe.



References   [ + ]

1. Immigrazione: il flop di Mare Nostrum, Il Sole 24 Ore
2. Caught in the act: NGOs deal in migrant smuggling, Gefira
3. NGOs Armada operating off the coast of Libya, Gefira
4. The Americans from MOAS ferry migrants to Europe, Gefira
5. How can EU action against migrant smuggling be more effective? European Commission
6. Andrea Riccardi, a soul for Europe, Lavie
7. Establishing Identity for International Protection, European Migration Network
8. Migrants, 40 fleeing hotel in Sulcis bloc and the anus State, Corriere
9. Cie revolt in Milan: flee three irregular, gd-notizie
10. Directed to the Cie, agents arrests 10, Migranti Torino
11. Lampedusa, via transfers. flight of immigrants from the cie in Turin, RAI
12. The illegal immigrants are in Italy after being expelled, Il Giornale
13. Mafia capital, Buzzi: “With immigrants will make a lot more money than with drugs”, Il Fatto Quotidiano
14. Sicilian Mafia Cashes In On Desperate Immigrants, La Stampa

4 comments on “Why the Italian government can’t resolve the problems of Mediterranean smuggling boats? Because it doesn’t want to

  • I’m Italian and this article is the truth. The sad thing is that italian mainstream media are also corrupted and NOBODY will ever investigate this matter.

    • Gitte Jensen says:

      I sympathize, but until people really agitate their local “representative” politicians nothing will happen. Meanwhile Italy will gradually lose its educated workforce to Germany, Canada, Australia etc… and increase the numbers of Africans, Albanians, Rumanians etc on the streets, unemployed and desperate. Demographic doomsday within ten years.

  • Gitte Jensen says:

    I continue to be astonished by the lack of effective action by Italy. I love Italy and visit whenever I can and I can see the country is being rapidly destroyed from within, complete failure to control its own borders on all sides.
    Now Australia had a similar problem with organized people trafficking a few years ago and have dealt with it firmly and very successfully as follows :

    1. Vessels carrying illegal migrant cargoes are intercepted by the Australian Navy and are turned back or where safe to do so towed back to port of origin (usually in Indonesia).

    2. Where smugglers sabotage or scupper their vessel to prevent action 1. then the crew are arrested and their human cargo sent to remote offshore islands OUTSIDE Australias migration zone for processing.

    3. After processing, whether found to be genuine bona fide refugee or not (mostly not), no-one is given right of entry into Australia. They are given the freedom to choose : returning to their own country , re-settlement in a third country ( Cambodia), register in a UNRWA camp in Indonesia, or remain in the offshore holding camps.

    4. The number assessed as genuine refugees is then added to the numerical quotas offered by Australia for those genuine refugees on waiting lists in UNRWA camps in Jordan, Lebanon, Turkey, and Kenya (Somalis) Thus Australia will now INCREASE its intake of approved refugees from Syria by 6 000 for 2016 by taking in extra people from Lebanon.

    As a result of this sensible and humanitarian policy the boats have stopped completely and NO lives have been lost at sea in 2016 from people smuggling ventures into Australian waters. In contrast at least 5 000 African migrants have drowned last year enroute from Libya by paying the people trafficker gangs, aided and actually encouraged by short-sighted, if not criminal, NGO activities.
    Italy is sleepwalking into a demographic and economic disaster and sorry to say it is mainly of their own doing by failing to tackle the problem before the other EU countries closed off their inner borders and let poor Italy become the dumping ground.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

GEFIRA provides in-depth and comprehensive analysis of and valuable insight into current events that investors, financial planners and politicians need to know to anticipate the world of tomorrow; it is intended for professional and non-professional readers.

Yearly subscription: 10 issues for €225/$250
Renewal: €160/$175

The Gefira bulletin is available in ENGLISH, GERMAN and SPANISH.