A few days ago while addressing the navy and the military personnel in St Petersburg Russia’s President Vladimir Putin said the words that sent shock waves in Poland and in Ukraine. He suggested in no uncertain times that the westernmost parts of Ukraine will sooner or later fall to Poland, Hungary, and Romania. Here are his exact words:
I am confident that sooner or later Ukraine will lose these western territories, lands that once belonged to Poland, Hungary and Romania. It may not happen tomorrow or the day after tomorrow. It may take one year, two years, 10 years or 15 years, but history will ultimately put everything back in its place.
Then Russia’s president went on to add that Ukraine’s integrity had only been guaranteed by Russia: without Russian protection Ukraine is going to lose the said territories. Again his precise words:
There was only one guarantor of Ukraine’s territorial integrity. It was Russia. But they decided it was necessary, possible and beneficial for them to declare Russia their enemy.
The Polish minister of foreign affairs hastened to state that Poland was not interested in any chunk of Ukrainian territory. Such a denial is simply a diplomatic reaction because historical reality and the current situation which Ukraine finds itself in may result in precisely the incorporation of the said parts of Ukraine into Poland, Hungary, and Romania.
Ukraine is in relation to Russia as Bavaria is in relation to Germany, or Provence is in relation to France, or Catalonia is in relation to Italy. We can draw many more similar comparisons. We have already stated on this website that the war between Ukraine and Russia is a fratricidal conflict. Both Russia and Ukraine (and also Belarus) trace their historical origins to Kievan Rus’. Kiev of all the cities is the cradle of all the Russian tribes that eventually evolved into different political entities, like today’s Belarus, Ukraine, and Russia.
But why did Putin say that westernmost chunks of Ukraine would eventually fall to Poland, Hungary, and Romania.? Simply because, for one thing, those territories to be parts of the said countries, and, for the other, because in case Ukraine becomes very much weakened by the ongoing conflict there may be no other solution as to incorporate parts of it into the said countries.
That’s nothing new in Ukraine’s history. Ukraine as such has never ever been an independent nation. (Even now it is independent in name only.) What Ukrainian historians point to as the medieval Ukrainian state was merely one Rus’ principality that existed for a very short span of time. Yes, three of its rulers are said to have been crowned kings, but the kings not of Ukraine; rather, of one of the many Russian medieval Russian principalities.
The name Ukraine did not imply a state or a kingdom or a country. The name Ukraine derives from the Slavic word that means edge, border, or borderland. That is why for instance we have a Krajina – a strip of land separating Croatia from Serbia. Croatia and Serbia are Slavic countries where Slavic languages are spoken, so they use the same term denoting a strip of land that separates two countries. To reiterate it, just as Krajina separates Croatia from Serbia, so does Ukraine separate Poland from Russia.
And, indeed, what today is known as Ukraine was part of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth for a couple of centuries. When towards the end of the 18th century this Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth disintegrated and its parts were incorporated into Prussia, Austria, and Russia, most of the present day Ukraine became a part of Russia, while its westernmost – heavily Polonized – parts were joined to Austria, which from 1867 was called Austria-Hungary.
After the First World War when Poland was reborn there were fierce fights over the control of the westernmost Ukraine. Poland won – and so chunks of Ukraine became part of Polish Republic. It was here that Ukrainian nationalism flourished.
The end of the Second World War meant that the state borders were redrawn. The territory of the Polish state was a shifted westward, while Polish eastern territories were incorporated into Lithuania, Belarus, and Ukraine, all of which had by then become soviet republics, parts of the Soviet Union.
Western Ukraine’s largest city is the city of Lvov. In the pre-war period it was the centre of Polish culture and science. The city was inhabited by Poles and also by Jews with Ukrainians making up a very small minority. The picture looked pretty much the same when you think about smaller towns in today’s Western Ukraine or pre-war eastern Poland: the lesser towns were inhabited by Poles or Jews. It was predominantly the villages were Ukrainians constituted the majority of population.
To give you another comparison: Western Ukraine was to Poland just as Scotland was or is to England or, indeed, (Northern) Ireland is to Britain. On the one hand Western Ukraine along with Scotland and Ireland have preserved their separate national identity, but on the other hand many Ukrainians just as a the majority of Scottish and Irish people have adopted the language of the conquerors. Ukrainian elites for the most part Polonized themselves just as Scottish and Irish upper classes felt drawn to the English language and culture.
If in today’s Poland there are national sentiments regarding the lost Eastern territories, they are insignificant if only because the new generations do not simply relate to the lost land. Though the sentiment is not strong, it does exist. A future political opportunity may translate into a political desire to incorporate westernmost parts of Ukraine into Poland.
Before 1991 barely anybody in West Germany thought about uniting the two German states. Certainly people dreamed about one Germany, but under the then circumstances they thought that unification was a matter of remote future, maybe a matter of 100 or 200 years. Yet, the moment a political opportunity presented itself, the unification of the two German States became possible and was effected. The German elites seized the opportunity without having planned the unification beforehand. As we know: politics is the art of the possible.
If we were into conspiracy theories, we might interpret President Vladimir Putin’s words in the following way. The Russian president made a proposal to Poland, Hungary and Romania. The proposal was to divide Ukraine between Russia, Poland, Hungary, and Romania rather than prolong the war and continue to live on hostile terms. Such agreements where two countries agree to divide a third one have been quite frequent throughout human history. Poland itself fell victim of such an agreement at the end of the 18th century. The partitions of Poland by Prussia, Austria, and Russia had not been planned for years before the event took place. It was simply that the opportunity presented itself and the opportunity was a very weak Poland, a Poland torn by internal factions, a Poland that was a politically incompetent and economically backward. The partitions entailed a relatively weak resistance: the final partition did not spark any resistance at all. The population was demoralized, economically exhausted, while its elites were politically incompetent. Indifference descended on almost the whole nation.
Consider today’s Ukraine. The country is weakened, its population has shrunk a lot, while Ukrainian men for the most part do not want to fight. They are brutally forced to to join the ranks. Very many of them have fled or live in hiding. If Ukraine were to be partitioned between Russia, Poland, Hungary, and Romania, the chances are the local populations would not resist such a move at all. So much so that by becoming a part of Poland, Hungary, or Romania, those Ukrainians would automatically become a part of the European Union, that is the part of that paradise that they had been dreaming about for decades. If at present millions of Ukrainians live in Poland, and in Hungary, and in Romania, if at present very many of them seek to be granted Polish, Hungarian, or Romanian citizenship, then why those who are left behind in Ukraine would like to resist becoming Polish, Hungarian or Romanian citizens?
People generally want to have a good life. If they cannot have a good life in Ukraine but they can have it in Poland, Hungary, or Romania, they will opt for it. Genuine patriots are rather few. The proof? The proof is the fact that several million of young Ukrainians have left the country evading being drafted into the Ukrainian army and thus defending their own country.
So, incorporation of Ukraine’s territory into the said three European countries? Partition of Ukraine? Not to be excluded. Sure enough, such changes will take time. it may happen in 10 or 20 years but such an eventuality is highly likely. There is nothing stable in politics or in life, in general. Even if today’s Polish government is distancing itself from any thoughts of incorporating parts of Ukraine, in 20 years’ time there will be new different governments and they may think differently.







